daggers (poison)

Suggestions
Player avatar

Konartiz61 Send PM

Member

Posts: 4

#119 May 2018 23:41

have asked a few mods recently they believe poison daggers should work against both npc and PvP but neither do

if poison arrows give poison damage then so should daggers?

cheers

Player avatar

Semirotta Send PM

Member

Posts: 456

#220 May 2018 09:02

Ofc that would make sense. Poison dagger, if you stab something with it; It should poison. No matter if it is during PvP or PvE.

Lol...

Player avatar

Billy Send PM

Former Admin

From: Ardougne
Posts: 2,997

#320 May 2018 09:36

What % odds do you think are fair to poison another player during PvP?

[img]https://i.imgur.com/3xbQmDo.gif[/img]Read the rules: Automated play is a bannable offense![img]https://i.imgur.com/HtElPYg.gif[/img]
lol Billy Mays' Quest Reviews lol

Player avatar

Konartiz61 Send PM

Member

Posts: 4

#420 May 2018 10:19

arrows seem like they poison tick fairly quick maybe make it equal to arrows?
as per the first initial hit would be random

Last edited by Konartiz61 (20 May 2018 10:20)

Player avatar

Nerdy Send PM

subscriber

Posts: 122

#520 May 2018 14:15

Billy said:

What % odds do you think are fair to poison another player during PvP?

Considering the damage difference in p2p of using a mele weapon vs arrows.. I would say it needs to be a) high enough to warrant use, b) high enough to matter as in taking up a 20-22 health slot in inventory.  When implemented I am sure people will bring anti/cure poison as a counter, so I think 40-50% is fair, as I think it will be countered easily.

Last edited by Nerdy (20 May 2018 14:16)

Player avatar

sirpyrrhic Send PM

Member

Posts: 330

#620 May 2018 14:46

i actually think it should lower thinking more along the line of poison being used in a ganking.  dont forget you can use protection from ranged in pvp.... but there is no protection form daggers in pvp.

I miss pking in chaos druid robes and bunny ears

Player avatar

Semirotta Send PM

Member

Posts: 456

#720 May 2018 16:31

IMO poison dagger should have 100% chance to psn player when hitting with it. If you get scratched with poison dagger irl, you will get poisoned.

Lol...

Player avatar

Synbios Send PM

subscriber

Posts: 406

#820 May 2018 17:41

Semirotta said:

IMO poison dagger should have 100% chance to psn player when hitting with it. If you get scratched with poison dagger irl, you will get poisoned.

I agree.

As it stands, rune dagger is pathetically weak thus the only merit it would have is the poison effect, which can easily be combated with the higher lvl anti-poison pot anyway.

Maybe not quite 100% PvM, but it should still be high enough to be worth using on higher lvl enemies like black demons.

Maybe even release dragon dagger as a slayer drop too.

Player avatar

adidas Send PM

subscriber

Posts: 1,080

#920 May 2018 19:48

Semirotta said:

IMO poison dagger should have 100% chance to psn player when hitting with it. If you get scratched with poison dagger irl, you will get poisoned.

nope. would be way too op.

Player avatar

Nerdy Send PM

subscriber

Posts: 122

#1020 May 2018 21:50

Synbios said:

Semirotta said:

IMO poison dagger should have 100% chance to psn player when hitting with it. If you get scratched with poison dagger irl, you will get poisoned.

I agree.

As it stands, rune dagger is pathetically weak thus the only merit it would have is the poison effect, which can easily be combated with the higher lvl anti-poison pot anyway.

Maybe not quite 100% PvM, but it should still be high enough to be worth using on higher lvl enemies like black demons.

Maybe even release dragon dagger as a slayer drop too.

I like, rather I love the idea of PVM poisons, AND on players.

Player avatar

Eww Bald Send PM

Member

From: Cyberspace
Posts: 344

#1121 May 2018 00:02

10%.

"I see..." said the blind man as he pissed into the wind "It's all coming back to me now!".

Player avatar

Semirotta Send PM

Member

Posts: 456

#1221 May 2018 08:42

How would it be op if it was 100% chance? psn dmg is really low, you can make it null via anti-poison potions. Basically it is super easy to counter. In PVE it also could be used more if it actually did poison things.

Lol...

Player avatar

Konartiz61 Send PM

Member

Posts: 4

#1321 May 2018 09:50

glad you guys have jumped on board with this!. if it's an item in the game it should have a purpose

Player avatar

Nerdy Send PM

subscriber

Posts: 122

#1421 May 2018 13:26

Semirotta said:

How would it be op if it was 100% chance? psn dmg is really low, you can make it null via anti-poison potions. Basically it is super easy to counter. In PVE it also could be used more if it actually did poison things.

Player avatar

Eww Bald Send PM

Member

From: Cyberspace
Posts: 344

#1521 May 2018 16:44

Its basic d&d that poisoning is not always successful.  Should there be no 0s in combat as well?

"I see..." said the blind man as he pissed into the wind "It's all coming back to me now!".

Player avatar

konartiz Send PM

Member

Posts: 13

#1623 May 2018 04:02

billy could we get this brought in as a trial?

Player avatar

konartiz Send PM

Member

Posts: 13

#176 Jun 2018 04:26

bump

Player avatar

b u b b a jr Send PM

Member

Posts: 79

#186 Jun 2018 05:07

on classic if u hit with a poison dagger u than poisoned them I'm almost positive.

[img]https://i.imgur.com/z2l3Zkl.png[/img]
[img]https://i.imgur.com/Rtt1WmN.png[/img]
[img]https://i.imgur.com/YBv5Ffx.png[/img]
[img]https://i.imgur.com/gu20rIS.png[/img]

Player avatar

Konartiz61 Send PM

Member

Posts: 4

#196 Jun 2018 09:32

correct

Suggestions