Since my hunt for a nature tally starting about 4-3 weeks ago I must have killed hundreds of reapers with a group of atleast 2 people, usually 3-4, but even 5+ at times.. so I would have an estimate that I've witnessed circa 2000 drops which included a handful of capes and even more hoods.. but not one nature tally..

Why is this so ridiculously rare? Unlike most people doing runecraft who stick to air runes because of the xp/time benefit I would actually like to use the other altars that you put effort in creating and aren't getting much use because, once I grind to 85 runecraft, it will be a great way for me to get natures on my iron man (main) character.